Books as Tools
Thomas' Rylands Early Printed Scientific Books
In his memoir of the Warrington wire-manufacturer and polymath Thomas Glazebrook Rylands (1818-1900), R.D. Radcliffe wrote:
Of his library he was justly proud. It consisted for the most part of books which he was wont to call his ‘tools’, and included nearly every important publication dealing with the subjects upon which he had worked.
(Memoir of Thomas Glazebrook Rylands, of Highfields, Thelwall, Cheshire, 1901, p. 41)
After Rylands’ death in 1900, he left 2700 of these ‘tools’ to University College Liverpool (now the University of Liverpool). On receipt of the bequest, the then Principal of the University, A.W.W. Dale agreed that for science and arts students alike, books are fundamental ‘tools’. He argued that all students should, therefore, have some understanding of the history of printing. As such:
a College Library is incomplete if it does not illustrate the stages of development, and the successive processes, through which the art of printing has passed (iii)
Rylands’ collection was particularly important in ensuring that the Liverpool College Library was appropriately furnished to illustrate the earliest stages in that development. The Rylands bequest included 19 medieval manuscripts and 72 incunabula – making it the biggest single donation of early printed books ever given to the University of Liverpool.
This exhibition was based on a cataloguing project and explores some of the many ways in which Rylands’ books have been used as tools. We focus on a small section of the bequest to show how the very earliest printed books supported Rylands' attempts at encyclopaedic mastery of two of his keenest interests - Geography and Astronomy.
Books as Tools
Thomas Glazebrook Rylands was interested in heraldry, and used a number of armorial bookplates and book stamps over the years. This interest in heraldry and books was shared by his son John Paul Rylands (1846-1923), who became something of an expert on bookplates.
Rylands’ younger son, William Harry Rylands (1847-1922), has left extensive bibliographical notes on the endpapers of this book. His notes and bookplate are present in a large number of the earliest printed books from the Rylands bequest, suggesting that he played an active role in the formation of the collection.
SPEC Inc.Ryl.10: Antoninus Florentinus, Confessionale. [Strasbourg]: Martin Flach, 1490.
Preferring to share the fruits of his studies directly with the very many learned societies to which he belonged, Rylands rarely opted to have these findings published more widely. The major exception to this rule was his 1893 work The Geography of Ptolemy Elucidated.
Rylands claims to have first encountered Ptolemy's (approx. 100-170 AD) geographical work a full 45 years earlier, but it was an 1872 Quaritch book sale of “about a dozens editions” of Ptolemy's Cosmographia, which proved the true catalyst for 20 years of careful study. Rylands purchased two editions of the Cosmographia from the sale, and was alarmed to discover how egregiously they differed.
SPEC Inc.Ryl.63: Ptolemy, Cosmographia (tr. Jacobus Angelus). [Ulm]: [Lienhart Holle], 1482.
Unable to rest without pursuing this troubling “difficulty” further, as Rylands wrote in the introduction to The Geography of Ptolemy:
A long and careful bibliographical study was undertaken, during which very nearly every printed edition, and not a few of the manuscripts, in the libraries at home and abroad, including the Vatican, were examined, and a score or two of critical points selected, which, with ordinary care, determined the heredity of a copy. (v)
SPEC Inc.Ryl.71: Registrum alphabeticum super octo libros Ptolomei incipit feliciter. [Rome]: [Petrus de Turre], [1490].
Thomas Glazebrook Rylands' notes on Ptolemy. Rylands frequently used his armorial bookplates as scrap paper for notes, as well as bookmarks, indicating sections of particular interest.
LUL MS.80: Rylands, Thomas Glazebrook. Notes on Ptolemy - 1873-93.
A photostat of "Vatican Atlas 3811" tipped in at the front of Rylands' copy of the 1482 Ulm edition of the Geographia. Rylands mentions a trip to the Vatican Library in the introduction to The Geography of Ptolemy Elucidated.
SPEC Inc.Ryl.63: Ptolemy, Cosmographia (tr. Jacobus Angelus). [Ulm]: [Lienhart Holle], 1482.
Rylands' notes on Ptolemy include a large number of tracings, here including a world map from a 1515 edition of Macrobius, and a tracing of the south coast of England, later used as Plate XIII in The Geography of Ptolemy Elucidated.
LUL MS.80: Rylands, Thomas Glazebrook. Notes on Ptolemy - 1873-93.
SPEC EP.Ryl.C08(01): Macrobius integer nitidus suo[que] decori a Ioanne Riuio restitutus: Cum indicio & amplo & veridice. [Paris]: Jean Petit, [1515].
In his introduction to The Geography of Ptolemy Elucidated, Rylands wrote that ‘the most fitting method of work seemed to be by diagrams’ (vi).
This diagrams of Ptolemy’s Scotland includes a modern map to the same scale. It was later used as the frontispiece to The Geography of Ptolemy Elucidated.
LUL MS.80: Rylands, Thomas Glazebrook. Notes on Ptolemy - 1873-93.
The Geography of Ptolemy Elucidated begins with "A brief outline of the rise and progress of geographical inquiry prior to the time of Ptolemy" (pages 1-16).
Here Rylands tells us that pre-scientific knowledge of the earth was infused with myth, with the first tentative steps towards a more scientific approach being made by philosophers, including Aristotle (384-322 BCE), Anaximander (approx. 610-546 BCE) and Thales (approx. 624-548 BCE). He considers the first figure to take a truly scientific approach to Geography to have been Pytheas of Massalia (approx 350-285 BCE) – ‘who combined the accuracy of an astronomer with the intrepidity of an explorer’ (2).
Pytheas’ own writings have not survived, but two works, both found in multiple editions in the Rylands bequest, are key sources of Pytheas’ account of his voyage to northwest Europe, as well as for the findings of Dicearchus (approx 350 - 285 BCE), Erastothenes (approx. 276 - 195 BCE), and Hipparchus (approx. 190 - 120 BCE) whose work Rylands summarises as key developments in the early history of Geography.
The Geographia of Strabo (64/63 BCE-c.24 CE) is described in the Oxford Classical Dictionary as “by far the most important source for ancient geography, a priceless document of the Augustan age, and a compendium of important material derived from lost authors”. Rylands cites Strabo regularly. Amongst a handful of editions of Strabo's work included in the Rylands bequest is this copy of the first Greek printed edition, which was produced at the Aldine Press, in 1516.
SPEC EP.Ryl.C07: Strabōn peri geōgraphias = Strabo de situ orbis. Venice: Haeredes Aldi Manutii Romani et Andreae Asulani Soceri, [1516].
Pliny's Historia Naturalis - an encyclopedic work which presents information on astronomy, anthropology, zoology, botany, drugs, medicine and magic, art history, agriculture, metallurgy, mineralogy and mining - is also a useful source of ancient geographical knowledge. Again, Rylands owned a number of copies of this book, both in Latin and in English. The earliest printed copy owned by Rylands was printed in Venice in 1487.
SPEC Inc.Ryl.51: Pliny the Elder, Naturalis Historiae Liber Primus. Venice: Marinus Saracenus, [1487].
Finally, the earliest Roman geographer, Pomponius Mela (active c.43 CE), was also present in multiple editions in Rylands' library, being another key text in his attempts to understand the course of geographical thinking before Ptolemy. His copy is another early printed book that shows signs of heavy use.
SPEC EP.Ryl.B18: Pomponius Mela, De situ orbis. [Cologne?]: [Eucharius Cervicornus and Hiero Fuchs for Ludwig Hornken?], [1522].
Astronomy
In 1865, Rylands built a two-storey observatory at his home in Warrington. From here, he sent regular astronomical observations to the Royal Astronomical Society (he also made notable meteorological contributions to the Royal Observatory, Greenwich).
In 1859 he gave a lecture to the Warrington Mechanics Institute entitled "The moon: its influences real and supposed", in which Radcliffe tells us "he gleaned from the works of old writers" (29). Here again, Rylands was concerned to understand his own studies within the context of a thorough mastery of the history of his subject. And in this endeavour his books were his most important tools. What you see here is a sample of the early printed books on astronomy and astrology owned by Rylands.
SPEC Inc.Ryl.47: Johannes Versor, Quaestiones super libros Aristotelis. [Cologne]: [Heinrich Quentell], [1489].
Aristotelian cosmology, which contrasted a central terrestrial region - comprised of the four elements, where there was coming to be and passing away; and an outer celestial region - comprised of imperishable aether, whose spheres generated the cyclic movements of the fixed stars and planets – long dominated Greek, Islamic, and Latin thinking concerning the nature of the universe (Hoskin: 13).
Printed in 1489, this incunable contains multiple layers of history in the marks of successive owners, including in the manuscript notes and diagrams which fill its endpapers, and help us understand the lasting influence of Aristotlean thinking.
SPEC Inc.Ryl.47: Johannes Versor, Quaestiones super libros Aristotelis. [Cologne]: [Heinrich Quentell], [1489].
Ptolemy (approx 100-170 AD) later developed a more mathematocal approach to Astronomy. His work, The Almagest - which included a catalogue of over 1000 stars, in 48 constellations, giving the lattitudes and longitudes and brightness of each - was the dominant text in Astronomy well into the medieval period.
The Compilatio astronomica of Al-Farghani (active 861) was a descriptive summary of Ptolemy’s Almagest, revised using the findings of earlier Islamic astronomers. This is a Latin translation printed at Ferrara in 1493.
SPEC Inc.Ryl.03: Al-Farghani, Compilatio astronomica (translated by John of Seville). Ferrara: Andreas Belfortis, [1493].
In 1543, Joannes Regiomontanus (1436-1476) and Georg von Peurbach (1423-1461) published an Epitome, an abridged Latin translation of Ptolemy’s Almagest. This translation was one of the most important sources on ancient astronomy in the Renaissance.
SPEC Ryl.N.2.22: Regiomontanus and Georg von Peurbach, Epitome of Ptolemy’s Almagest. Basil: Heinrich Petri, [1543].
The endpapers of this 1475 copy of Ptolemy's Cosmographia comprise two parchment leaves of astronomical tables for Cremona, Italy, in blue, red and yellow and green ink.
SPEC Inc.Ryl.35: Ptolemy, Cosmographia. Vicenza: [Hermann Lichtenstein], [1475].
This book, printed in 1490, contains two of the most influential medieval astronomical textbooks - Sphaera mundi of Joannes Sacro Bosco (active 1230) and Theoricae novae planetarum of Georg von Peurbach (1423-1461). This is also a relatively early example of experiments in printing with colour.
SPEC Inc.Ryl.22(01): Johannes Sacro Bosco, Sphaera mundi. Venice: Ottaviano Scotto, [1490].
Another work heavily influenced by Ptolemy, the 1524 Cosmographicus liber of Peter Apian (1495-1552), epitomises the idea of books as tools, incorporating a number of volvelles: paper instruments with movable parts which could be turned in order to make calculations or predictions - to calculate the position of the sun, moon and planets, or to calculate lattitude from the height of the sun above the horizon, for example.
SPEC EP.Ryl.B28(01): Peter Apian, Cosmographicus liber. Landshut: Johann Weyssenburger, [1524].
C. Julius Hyginus’ Poetica astronomica tells the myths connected to the constellations. It was printed in 1482 by one of the earliest publishers of scientific and mathematical works, Erhard Ratdolt (1442-1528). A number of the early printed books in the Rylands collection contain woodcut illustrations of the constellations.
SPEC Inc.Ryl.04: C. Julius Hyginus, Poetica astronomia. Venice: [Erhard Ratdolt], 1482.